Acute and subchronic toxicological evaluation of Echinophora platyloba DC (Apiaceae) total extract in Wistar rats

OBJECTIVE:

Echinophora platyloba DC is a widely used herbal medicine and food seasoning in Iran. It is claimed to exert antimicrobial, antifungal, and antispasmodic effects. Despite the prevalent use of this plant as a food and medicine, there are no reports on its possible toxic effects. To evaluate the safety of E. platyloba, we tested its acute and sub-chronic toxicity in male and female Wistar rats.

METHODS:

Rats were orally treated with four different single doses of E. platyloba total extract and screened for signs of toxicity two weeks after administration. In the sub-chronic toxicity study, E. platyloba was administered for 45 days. Mortality, clinical signs, body weight changes, hematological and biochemical parameters, gross findings, organ weights, and histological markers were monitored during the study.

RESULTS:

We found no mortality and no abnormality in clinical signs, body weight, or necropsy findings in any of the animals in the acute study. The results of the subchronic study showed no significant difference in hematological parameters in either sex. There was a significant increase in lactate dehydrogenase in the female groups. A significant increase in the relative lung weight of female rats was noted at 500 mg/kg. Histopathological examinations revealed intra-alveolar hemorrhage in the male rats (500 mg/kg). In the females, congestion of the alveolar capillaries (at 500 mg/kg) and liver bridging necrosis (at 200 mg/kg) were significantly increased.

CONCLUSION:

The no observed adverse effect level of E. platyloba was determined to be 200 and 50 mg/kg for male and female rats, respectively.

INTRODUCTION

The Apiaceae family is of particular interest in food and medicinal chemistry because it includes many commonly consumed plants, such as celery, carrot, fennel, caraway, and dill. Coumarins, polyacetylenes, flavonoids, sesquiterpenes, and phthalides are among the important chemical constituents of this family, along with biologically active essential oils (1–5). Iran's climate conditions are especially suitable for the growth of apiaceous plants, as demonstrated by the growth of 114 wild genera with 12 endemic genera (6), most of which are consumed daily as food or used in traditional medicine.

Echinophora is a ten-species genus of Apiaceae that contains four species native to Iran, including E. orientalis, E. sibthorpiana, E. cinerea, and E. platyloba (6). Called “Khousharizeh” or “Tigh Touragh” in Persian, E. platyloba is widely used in western and central Iran as a food seasoning and edible vegetable. Local people add the plant to pickles and tomato pastes as an antifungal and antimicrobial preservative (7). These effects have been demonstrated in several experiments. For example, alcoholic extracts of E. platyloba inhibited Candida albicans (7), Trichophyton spp., Microsporum (8), Pseudomonas, and Staphylococcus growth, but it was not effective against Aspergillus (9). Moreover, it could increase the effect of amphotericin B against C. albicans (10). E. platyloba is also traditionally used as an antispasmodic in dysmenorrhea, and its efficacy was proven in a clinical trial (11). Moreover, its hydroalcoholic extract and essential oil were shown to have acceptable antispasmodic effects in the rat ileum (12).

Despite the widespread folk uses and pharmacological effects of E. platyloba, there have been no toxicological studies on its safety. Therefore, in this study, we investigated the acute and repeated-dose (45 days) toxicity of E. platyloba in Wistar rats.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Plant material and hydroalcoholic extract preparation

The aerial parts of the plant were collected from Charmahal-Bakhtiary, Iran, in April 2009 and dried away from direct sunlight. The plant was authenticated by M. K., and a voucher specimen (Registration Number 1030) was deposited in the Herbarium of the School of Pharmacy (Shaheed Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran). The plant samples were ground to fine powder and macerated with EtOH:H₂O (80:20) three times. The extract was concentrated to dryness first via eliminating EtOH in a rotary evaporator and then removing the H₂O by freeze drying.

Evaluation of toxicity following a single-dose administration

Four-week-old Wistar rats of both sexes were purchased from Razi Research Institute (Hesarak, Karaj, Iran) and acclimated to holding facilities for two weeks prior to dosing. The animals were randomly assigned to control and four treatment groups (five rats per sex per group) and housed in clear plastic cages containing wood shavings for bedding. Each cage contained five rats of the same sex fed normal laboratory chow (Pars Co., Tehran, Iran) and tap water ad libitum throughout the study. Environmental conditions were maintained at 23±2 °C and a relative humidity of 40±10% with a 12 h light/dark cycle. At the onset of dosing, the males weighed 164±19 g, and the females weighed 142±15 g. The research was conducted in accordance with internationally accepted principles for laboratory animal use and care (NIH Publication no. 85–23, revised in 1985).

Administration

The animals were fasted for 4 h prior to dosing. The extract was administered by gavage at doses of 50, 500, 1,000, and 2,000 mg/kg body weight. The control rats received tap water by gavage in the same volume.

Observations

The rats were observed for clinical signs prior to dosing, at 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 h post-dosing and daily thereafter for 14 days. They were also monitored daily for mortality, any changes in food and water consumption, and any additional clinical or behavioral signs of toxicity. The animal body weights were measured prior to dosing and on days 7 and 14. The numbers of dead animals in each group at the end of the study were expressed as a percentage, and when possible, the LD₅₀ value was established using the Probit method (13). All of the animals were sacrificed on day 15.

Evaluation of toxicity following subchronic treatment

Group assignment and treatment

The animals were randomly caged in clear plastic cages containing wood shavings for bedding. Dosing was initiated when the rats were 8 weeks old, at which point the males and females weighed 200±19 g and 161±10 g, respectively. The animals were divided into four dose groups (five rats per sex per group). The first group was given 1 ml normal saline and used as a control. The second, third, and fourth groups were given single doses of 50, 200, and 500 mg/kg of E. platyloba by gavage daily. All of the solutions were prepared just prior to dosing and were kept chilled and tightly capped.

In vivo observations

Observations of mortality and toxicological signs were made daily for 45 days. The onset, intensity, and duration of these symptoms, if any, were recorded. The weight of each rat was recorded on day 0 and at weekly intervals throughout the course of the study. Food and water consumption was measured three times per week.

Biochemical and hematology analysis

After 45 days, 12 h-fasted animals were anesthetized with the IP injection of a mixture containing ketamine (40 mg/kg) and xylazine (10 mg/kg). The jugular vein was exposed, and blood samples were obtained by jugular vein puncture (14). The following hematological parameters were determined with the Sysmex K-1000 fully automated hematology analyzer: erythrocyte (RBC), total and differential leukocyte (WBC), hematocrit (Hct), hemoglobin (Hb), platelet count, mean corpuscular volume (MCV), mean corpuscular hemoglobin (MCH), mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration (MCHC), mean platelet volume (MPV), platelet distribution width (PDW), and red distribution width (RDW). Blood samples for biochemical analyses were centrifuged at 3,000×g for 5 min, and the plasma was collected and analyzed for glucose, uric acid, creatinine, albumin, cholesterol, low-density lipoprotein (LDL), high-density lipoprotein (HDL), very low-density lipoprotein (VLDL), triglycerides, aspartate aminotransferase (AST), alanine aminotransferase (ALT), urea, total protein, and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) using a COBAS Mira S chemistry analyzer (Roche Diagnostic Systems, West Sussex, England).

Necropsy

Following blood collection, the rats were sacrificed by decapitation, and the organs identified in Table 3 were removed, weighed, and examined macroscopically. The organs were then preserved in 10% neutral buffered formalin and prepared for microscopic histopathological examinations.

Table 3.

Relative organ weight at termination of treatment with E. platyloba (g % body weight).

Sex	Dose mg/kg	liver%	kidney%	Heart%	Lung%
Male	Control	2.9±0.136	0.76±0.024	0.4±0.072	0.56±0.024
	50	3.03±0.21	0.79±0.04	0.378±0.015	0.66±0.04
	200	2.86±0.15	0.79±0.066	0.34±0.024	0.71±0.08
	500	3.07±0.28	0.83±0.05	0.39±0.055	0.54±0.03
Female	Control	4±0.2	0.79±0.1	0.38±0.009	0.59±0.036
	50	3.1±0.25	0.822±0. 052	0.41±0.006	0.67±0. 03
	200	3.03±0.14	0.831±0.0052	0.37±0.031	063±0.056
	500	3.26±0.28	0.88±0.04	0.4±0.032	0.80±0.07∗

Data presented as mean±S.E.M. for n = 5. Significantly different from control: ∗p < 0.05.

Statistics

The mean±SEM was calculated for body weights, food consumption, organ/body weight ratios, and hematological and biochemistry factors. The difference between dose groups and controls was separately evaluated for males and females with a one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Tukey's test. p-values of 0.05 or less were considered to be significant. Because no treatment-related animal deaths were observed, the LD50 values were not measured.

RESULTS

Acute study

All of the rats treated with different concentrations of total extracts of E. platyloba were alive for all 14 days of observation. Normal body weight gains were observed in the males and females of all of the dose groups. No abnormal gross findings were observed in any of the animals. The oral acute toxicity of E. platyloba total extract (LD50) was therefore considered to be unclassified; doses up to 2,000 g/kg did not induce death or toxic symptoms.

Subchronic study

There was no significant difference in body weights between the control and treatment groups (Figures 1 and 2). There was no significant difference between the food consumption of E. platyloba-treated animals and controls. No death was found in any of the groups throughout the experimental period, and no abnormal gross findings were observed in any of the animals. The results of the hematological study are shown in Table 1. No treatment-related changes in hematological parameters were observed during the study period. Biochemical parameter evaluation showed an increase in LDH levels in the 200 and 500 mg/kg female groups (Table 2). No significant differences were observed between the vehicle control and E. platyloba treatment groups in the other biochemical parameters, such as ALT, AST, creatinine, and/or urea. Organ weights measured at necropsy showed increases in the relative lung weights of the 500 mg/kg-treated female rats (Table 3). Histopathological examinations showed intra-alveolar hemorrhage in the male rats (500 mg/kg). In the female rats, congestion of the alveolar capillaries (at 500 mg/kg) and liver bridging necrosis (at 200 mg/kg) were significantly increased compared with the control group. No changes were observed in any of the other parameters evaluated, including alveolar collapse, septal thickness, interstitial infiltrate, intra-alveolar neutrophil counts, alveolar edema, and fatty changes in the lung, hepatocyte regeneration/degeneration, architectural distortion, necrosis, interface hepatitis, portal infiltration, and obstruction/dilatation of the bile duct in the liver. No histological findings in the kidney or heart could be attributed to the E. platyloba treatment.

Figure 1.

Changes in male (A) and female (B) rats body weight with duration of acute treatment. Each point represents mean±SEM, n = 5.

Figure 2.

Changes in male (A) and female (B) rats body weight with duration of subchronic treatment. Each point represents mean±SEM, n = 5.

Table 1.

Hematologic parameters in Wistar rats after 45 days treatment with E. platyloba.

Sex	Group	WBC(/µl)	RBC(10^6/mm^3)	Hb(g%)	HCT(%)
Male	Control	11200±521	9.22±0.1	16.4±0.24	48.17±0.46
	50	9900±1121.45	8.21±0.3	16.01±0.1	46.2±0.45
	200	9300.23±645.23	8.28±0.5	14.6±0.09	44.4±0.42
	500	8700.65±1117.89	7.66±0.9	15.8±0.6	44.7±0.8
Female	Control	7700.89±189.49	7.46±0.1	14.77±0.1	39.1±0.6
	50	8700±425.25	7.1±0.07	14.36±0.02	37.46±0.2
	200	7300±202.45	7±0.2	13.6±0.1	36.45±0.4
	500	7700±1128.06	7.5±0.1	13.3±0.07	36.4±1.1

Sex	Group	MCV(fi)	MCH(pg)	MCHC(%)	MPV(fi)
Male	Control	53±0.06	18±0	34.3±0.25	7.2±0.25
	50	52.6±0.3	18±0	35.25±0.25	7.4±0.23
	200	58.62±0.4	18±0.05	34.75±0.25	6.7±0.18
	500	50.66±0.06	21.3±2.5	35.75±0.9	9.3±0.89
Female	Control	52.75±0.06	20.3±0.25	38.3±0.25	6.7±0.1
	50	52.25±0.45	20±2.3	37.75±0.05	6.66±0.05
	200	52±0.8	21.41±3.6	37±0	6.65±0.1
	500	51.75±0.9	18.1±2.37	36.5±1.1	6.5±0.1

Sex	Group	Platelets(1000/µl)	RDW(%)	PDW(%)
Male	Control	819.58±142	13.3±0.2	8.65±1
	50	841.98±56.32	13.1±0.08	8.4±0.1
	200	875.6±69.22	13.1±0.34	7.63±0.2
	500	800.36±98.3	13.05±0.3	7.6±0.2
Female	Control	935±52	12.25±0.21	7.62±0.1
	50	854.23±25.4	12.1±0.3	7.52±0.2
	200	921.89±89.6	12±0.31	7.4±0.05
	500	732.6±124.3	11.9±0.1	7.17±0.2

Data presented as mean±S.E.M. for N = 5.

Table 2.

Biochemical parameters of Wistar rats after 45 days treatment with E.platyloba.

Sex	Dose mg/kg	blood sugar(mg/dl)	Creatinine (mg/dl)	Uric Acid (mg/dl)	Triglycerides(mg/dl)
Male	Control	162±10.19	0.42±0.02	2.96±0.9	55.2±7.13
	50	202.6±23.02	0.42±0.04	2.5±0.54	48±7.34
	200	219.65±23.75	0.54±0.05	3.92±0.73	68.8±6.7
	500	379.5±4.05	0.57±0.09	2.97±0.35	72.8±17.6
Female	Control	291.3±28.34	0.5±0.05	5±0.65	82.2±15. 5
	50	151.4±11.9∗	0.44±0.05	4.14±0.84	66.6±11.25
	200	148.2±2.7∗	0.5±0.0	3.78±0.0.51	52±8.24
	500	177.6±23.64	0.46±0.06	3.08±0.99	62±6.1

Sex	Dose mg/kg	Cholesterol(mg/dl)	HDL(mg/dl)	LDL(mg/dl)	VLDL(mg/dl)
Male	Control	72±7.17	38.4±4.67	22.4±3.3	11.2±1.3
	50	84.2±4.93	48.4±7.6	26.2±6.5	9.6±7.4
	200	76.4±4.26	34.6±4.2	27.4±5.7	14.4±1.63
	500	92.25±4.75	43±6.67	36.25±7.6	13±0.7
Female	Control	112.4±9.6	69.5±6.7	21.5±3.8	16.6±1.69
	50	91±3.8	91±3.8	34.6±5.6	13.2±2.1
	200	88.6±6.67	89.2±6.4	28±7.7	10.4±1.72
	500	98.2±7.37	92±5.14	33.8±6.2	12.4±1.28

Sex	Dose mg/kg	Urea(g %)	SGOT(IU/L)	SGPT(IU/L)	LDH(U/L)
Male	Control	41.6±1.91	130.8±16.25	48±4.84	942.8±138.7
	50	45±4.48	144±19.45	58±6.39	1293±189.13
	200	50±3.59	170.4±16.7	61.25±10.2	2036.6±117.98∗
	500	52.5±1.65	191±15.02	71.25±7.2	2043±122.88∗
Female	Control	60±6.15	184.2±26.02	66.8±9.84	2126±137.12
	50	57.8±6.03	206.2±20.63	71±9.18	1992.4 ±243.18
	200	46.6±3.57	122.8±5.21	41±1.5	1743.3±37.6
	500	56.4±4.83	126.8±14.51	52.4±2	1555.25±86.96

Sex	Dose mg/kg	Albumin(gr/dl)	Total Protein(mg/dl)
Male	Control	3.98±0.15	9.12±0.56
	50	3.59±0.1	8.97±0.39
	200	3.25±0.16	8.56±0.48
	500	3.73±0.19	8.75±0.72
Female	Control	3.32±0.26	7.86±0.6
	50	2.84±0.17	7.69±0.52
	200	3.13±0.33	8.14±0.69
	500	3.76±0.18	7.39±0.49

Data presented as mean±S.E.M. for N = 5. Significantly different from control: ∗p < 0.05.

DISCUSSION

Complementary and alternative medicines (CAMs), such as herbal remedies, require thorough safety and efficacy evaluation due to their growing use all over the world (15). Although many traditional herbal remedies are available and some have been verified by clinical trials, their safety is often still questioned by consumers.

E. platyloba DC is native to Iran and is used in traditional medicine and consumed as a vegetable (7,16).

Despite preliminary evidence of its therapeutic benefits, no toxicology studies have been performed on E. platyloba extracts. In the present study, the acute and subchronic toxicity of E. platyloba DC was evaluated in Wistar rats. The oral LD50 value in this study suggests that E. platyloba DC is a relatively nontoxic plant (17).

Generally, reductions in body weight gain and internal organ weights are considered to be simple and sensitive indices of toxicity after exposure to toxic substances (18). Oral gavage of E. platyloba at up to 500 mg/kg in male and female Wistar rats was not associated with any mortality or abnormality in their general condition, behavior, growth, food and water consumption, or body weight. Additionally, treatment with E. platyloba extract did not produce any statistically significant difference in hematological parameters. The observed elevation in LDH, an initial indicator of myopathy, in females indicates the potential for muscular damage. LDH levels can be diagnostic of myocardial or skeletal muscle injuries (14), but there were no treatment-related heart histopathological findings. Thus, the potential effects of E. platyloba treatment on cardiac muscle should be investigated further.

A significant increase in relative lung weight was also observed. This phenotype may have been caused by the congestion of the alveolar capillaries by retaining blood in the lung. Moreover, the intra-alveolar hemorrhage observed in the male rats (500 mg/kg) indicates that E. platyloba DC may have some effects on this organ. The liver bridging necrosis observed in female rats (200 mg/kg) was not dose–dependent and therefore was not considered to be a treatment-related effect. Additionally, no indicators of liver injury, such as ALT and AST, were observed.

Based on the results of this study, the no observed adverse effect level (NOAEL) of total E. platyloba extract was considered to be 200 and 50 mg/kg/day for male and female rats, respectively. This result indicates that gender is one factor that could influence the response to E. platyloba, and females are more sensitive than males to its subchronic toxicity.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

Mirghazanfari SM designed and organized the study. Hosseinzadeh L interpreted the results, performed data analysis, and revised the manuscript. Shokoohinia Y was responsible for plant extract preparation and drafting the introduction, discussion and conclusion sections of the manuscript. Aslani M was responsible for animal experiments and data collection. Kamali-Nejad M was responsible for plant identification and data collection.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This study was financially supported by the Research Council of Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran.