metricas

Radiología (English Edition)

Suggestions
Radiología (English Edition) Analysis of the management of occult fractures of the scaphoid through early mag...
Journal Information
Vol. 55. Issue 3.
Pages 185-278 (May - June 2013)
Cite
Cite
Share
Download PDF
More article options
Visits
6969
Vol. 55. Issue 3.
Pages 185-278 (May - June 2013)
Original Report

Analysis of the management of occult fractures of the scaphoid through early magnetic resonance imaging

Visits
6969
M.D. Moreno-Ramos
Corresponding author
lola67@wanadoo.es

Corresponding author.
, M. Martínez-Hervás, P. Sanz-Rupp, J. Ramos-Medrano
Servicio de Radiodiagnóstico, Hospital San Juan de Dios del Aljarafe, Bormujos, Sevilla, Spain
This item has received
Article information
Abstract
Full Text
Bibliography
Download PDF
Statistics
Abstract
Introduction

We aimed to evaluate the usefulness of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the diagnosis of occult fractures of the scaphoid and to determine the advantages and cost in comparison with the traditional follow-up protocol.

Materials and methods

The traditional approach at our center consisted of immobilization and periodic clinical and radiological follow-up (plain-film X-rays and computed tomography in the final phase of the process). The new protocol called for a limited MRI study consisting of coronal T1- and T2-weighted fat suppression sequences if the findings at plain-film X-rays continued to be negative at the first follow-up examination with the traumatologist (10 days after trauma). We evaluated the MRI findings, the time the patient was immobilized, the cost of each protocol, and the dose of radiation received.

Results

We included 33 cases of patients with clinically suspected fractures of the scaphoid and negative findings on plain-film X-rays. In 13 patients, the MRI findings were negative. In 12 patients, the MRI findings confirmed the diagnosis of a fracture of the scaphoid, which was associated with other pathology in 6 cases. In 8 patients, another pathological process was diagnosed. The cost of the new protocol was €131.06 per patient; the cost of the traditional protocol was €114.41 or €151.06 per patient, depending on the follow-up studies required. The new protocol reduced the dose of radiation by eliminating successive radiologic studies.

Conclusions

The new protocol improved the management of these patients, reducing the time of immobilization, improving joint rigidity, and reducing the time off work. The limited MRI study makes it possible to diagnose other radiologically occult lesions. The cost of the new protocol is similar to that of the traditional protocol and even lower in some cases. The new protocol results in a reduction in the dose of radiation.

Keywords:
Scaphoid bone
Fracture
Magnetic resonance imaging
Cost analysis
Resumo
Introducción

Nuestro objetivo es valorar la utilidad de la resonancia magnética (RM) en el diagnóstico de las fracturas ocultas de escafoides, mostrando las ventajas y el coste comparativo frente al protocolo de seguimiento tradicional.

Material y método

El protocolo de actuación tradicional en nuestro centro, consistía en inmovilización y revisiones clínico-radiológicas periódicas (radiología convencional y tomografía computarizada en la fase final del proceso). En el nuevo protocolo, si en el primer control del traumatólogo (10 días post- traumatismo) la radiología convencional seguía siendo negativa se realizaba un protocolo limitado de RM de muñeca (coronal T1 y T2-supresión grasa). Se valoraron los hallazgos visualizados en RM, tiempo de inmovilización del paciente, coste económico de ambos protocolos y dosis de radiación recibida.

Resultados

Se incluyeron 33 casos de pacientes con sospecha clínica de fractura de escafoides y radiología negativa. En 13 pacientes la RM fue negativa. En 12 se confirmó el diagnóstico de fractura de escafoides, 6 asociadas a otra patología. En 8 se diagnosticó otro proceso. El coste del nuevo protocolo fue de 131.06€ por paciente y de 114.41€ ó151.06€ para el tradicional, según las revisiones necesarias. Se redujo la dosis de radiación al eliminar la realización de sucesivas exploraciones radiológicas.

Conclusiones

El nuevo protocolo mejora el manejo de estos pacientes, reduciendo el tiempo de inmovilización, mejorando la rigidez articular y disminuyendo el periodo de baja laboral. Permite el diagnóstico de otras lesiones radiológicamente ocultas. El coste es similar, e incluso inferior en algunos casos, y la irradiación es menor.

Article

These are the options to access the full texts of the publication Radiología (English Edition)
Subscriber
Subscriber

If you already have your login data, please click here .

If you have forgotten your password you can you can recover it by clicking here and selecting the option “I have forgotten my password”
Purchase
Purchase article

Purchasing article the PDF version will be downloaded

Purchase now
Contact
Phone for subscriptions and reporting of errors
From Monday to Friday from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. (GMT + 1) except for the months of July and August which will be from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Calls from Spain
932 415 960
Calls from outside Spain
+34 932 415 960
E-mail
References
[1]
T.A. Dorsay, N.M. Major, C.A. Helms.
Cost-effectiveness of immediate MR imaging versus traditional follow-up for revealing radiographically occult scaphoid fractures.
Am J Roentgenol, 177 (2001), pp. 1257-1263
[2]
A. Blum, B. Sauer, R. Detreille, J.P. Zabel, F. Pierrucci, Y. Witte, et al.
Le diagnostic de fractures récentes du scaphöide: revue de la littérature. The diagnosis of recent scaphoid fractures: review of the literature.
J Radiol, 88 (2007), pp. 741-759
[3]
B. Munk, J. Frøkjaer, C.F. Larsen, H.G. Johannsen, L.L. Rasmussen, A. Edal, et al.
Diagnosis of scaphoid fractures. A prospective multicenter study of 1,052 patients with 160 fractures.
Acta Orthop Scand, 66 (1995), pp. 359-360
[4]
A.M. Groves, I. Kayani, R. Syed, B.F. Hutton, P.P.W. Bearcroft, A.K. Dixon, et al.
An international survey of hospital practice in the imaging of acute scaphoid trauma.
Am J Roentgenol, 187 (2006), pp. 1453-1456
[5]
Z.G. Yin, J.B. Zhang, S.L. Kan, X.G. Wang.
Diagnosing suspected scaphoid fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
Clin Orthop Relat Res, 468 (2010), pp. 723-734
[6]
Fraile E, González I, Martínez J, Martínez V, Morales A, Nombela L, et al. Catálogo de exploraciones radiológicas (4.a edición). SERAM 2009. Website de la Sociedad Española de Radiología Médica SERAM [updated September 2009, accessed June 2011]. Available in: http://www.seram.es/attachments/353_CATALOGO%20SERAM%202009_final.pdf.
[7]
A. Pillai, M. Jain.
Management of clinical fractures of the scaphoid: results of an audit and literature review.
Eur J Emerg Med, 12 (2005), pp. 47-51
[8]
M. Memarsadeghi, M.J. Breitenseher, C. Schaefer-Prokop, M. Weber, S. Aldrian, C. Gäbler, et al.
Occult scaphoid fractures: comparison of multidetector CT and MR imaging-initial experience.
Radiology, 240 (2006), pp. 169-176
[9]
I. Calvo Lorenzo, M.C. Ayestaran Vega.
Evolución de los traumatismos agudos de muñeca radiológicamente negativos. Estudio prospectivo.
Patología del Aparato Locomotor, 5 (2007), pp. 31-39
[10]
A. Brydie, N. Raby.
Early MRI in the management of clinical scaphoid fracture.
Br J Radiol, 76 (2003), pp. 296-300
[11]
J.C. Hunter, E.M. Escobedo, A.J. Wilson, D.P. Hanel, G.C. Zink-Brody, F.A. Mann.
MR imaging of clinically suspected scaphoid fractures.
Am J Roentgenol, 168 (1997), pp. 1287-1293
[12]
P. Saffar.
Cal vicieux du scaphoïde. Scaphoid malunion.
Chir Main, 27 (2008), pp. 65-75
[13]
A. Gooding, M. Coates, A. Rothwell.
Cost analysis of traditional follow-up protocol versus MRI for radiographically occult scaphoid fractures: a pilot study for the Accident Compensation Corporation.
N Z Med J, 117 (2004), pp. U1049
[14]
T.B. Hansen, R.B. Petersen, J. Barckman, P. Uhre, K. Larsen.
Cost-effectiveness of MRI in managing suspected scaphoid fractures.
J Hand Surg Eur, 34 (2009), pp. 627-630
[15]
L. Adey, J.S. Souer, S. Lozano-Calderon, W. Palmer, S.G. Lee, D. Ring.
Computed tomography of suspected scaphoid fractures.
J Hand Surg Am, 32 (2007), pp. 61-66
asdasdasd
Article options
Tools